Trakya Univ J Sci
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
After
filling the form, Referee’s
Evaluation Sheet
Please
return to: Please
do not write your name or signature on this form
Trakya Universitesi
Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü
Güllapoğlu Yerleşkesi
22030 Edirne - TURKEY
Tel :
+90 284 2358230
Fax :
+90 284 2358237
e-mail :
kamilk@trakya.edu.tr
MS number :
Title of MS :
Author (s) :
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I read above MS and give comments below (Please check if
appropriate for you)
□ Research Article
□ Review Article □
Short
Communication □ Letter to the Editor □ Book Review □ Other
Decision Language Needs Priority Quality of MS
□ Accepted, no any change □ No
correction □ High □ Excellent
□ Accepted, needs minor revision □ Correction □ Medium □ Good
□ Accepted, needs condense □ Major
correction □ Low □ Acceptable
□ Needs major revision □ Rewriting □ Bad
□ Reject
Is the MS within the scope of the journal? □ Yes □ No □ See
Comments
Do the author(s) conclusions data’s well? □ Yes □ No □ Partially □ See
Comments
Are the results important? □ Yes □ No □ Partially □ See
Comments
Is the subdivision into chapters clear? □ Yes □ No □ See
Comments
Are the results original? □ Yes □ No □
Partially □ See
Comments
Title □ Acceptable □ Needs
changing
Is the title clearly and coverage of the MS? □ Yes □ No □ See
Comments
Are the keywords adequate? □ Yes □ No □ See
Comments
Number of references □ Adequate □ inadequate □ Too
high □ See
Comments
Illustrations □ Adequate □ Excessive □ duplicity
with tables □ Inadequate
□ See Comments
Are the captions of the figures and tables appropriate? □ Yes □ No □
Partially □ See
Comments
Style of the MS □ Acceptable □ too brief □ Too long □ Poorly
arranged
□ Does not
follow guide for authors □ See
Comments
Does MS contribute to the science? □ Yes □ No □ Widening of
knowledge □ To the method
□ See Comments
If you do not want to review the article due to any reason,
may you suggest alternative referees with their addresses and e-mails?
Further Comments:
(Please filling here, we can need contact with you again, thank you)
Name, surname and mailing address of the referee:
Tel : Date: e-mail:
Signature: